Pilgrimage Pathways: Burial Monuments and Road Networks in Early Roman Jerusalem

Cercetări Arheologice 31.2, 2024, 347-378
https://doi.org/10.46535/ca.31.2.05



Pilgrimage Pathways: Burial Monuments and Road Networks in Early Roman Jerusalem

Authors: Boaz Zissu Omri Abadi

Keywords:

Monumental tombs, Jerusalem, Second Temple period, ancient roads, pilgrimage.

Abstract:

Several clusters of monumental tombs from the Early Roman period have been found in the vicinity of Jerusalem. Monumental tombs are characterized by their size, grandeur, and exceptional decorations, which surpass functional requirements. They may be constructed or carved out of rock, sometimes with an impressive monument built above or beside them that stands out in the surrounding area. Dozens of burial complexes with monumental characteristics, most of them dated to the last century of the Second Temple period (ca. 37 BCE to 66 CE), have been discovered in Jerusalem. Although the number of monumental tombs is small compared to that of standard tombs from this period, the phenomenon has received significant attention from scholars. Numerous studies have analyzed these tombs, focusing on chronological, architectural, and artistic aspects. However, their significance and location have been largely overlooked. This article addresses these issues.

Cemeteries in major cities of the Roman Empire were often located along the main roads leading to the city. However, a comprehensive analysis of the association between roads and cemeteries in Early Roman–period Jerusalem is still lacking, despite extensive studies on burials in the area. While it is unlikely that all tombs around Jerusalem were created alongside roads, it is plausible that the location of some monumental tombs was determined by the presence of nearby roads.

The article begins with a brief overview of the status of Jerusalem during the Second Temple period, the phenomenon of pilgrimage to the Temple during the Late Hellenistic (Hasmonean) and Early Roman periods, and the practice of monumental burial in the city during this time. We will then focus on two clusters of monumental tombs on the outskirts of Jerusalem that may have been carved alongside main roads to the city— the Sanhedria tombs and the Kidron Valley tombs—examining the characteristics of the monumental tomb clusters, ancient roads discovered nearby, and the association between the monuments and the roads. Following this, we will propose a potential reconstruction of certain routes that may have been used by pilgrims.

We conclude with a closer examination of the Kidron Valley, including additional archaeological evidence from the City of David and its surroundings. We will trace the path of the road from the Kidron Valley through the entrance to the city and up to the Temple Mount in an effort to understand the rationale behind it.

Download: PDF

How to cite: Boaz Zissu, Omri Abadi, Pilgrimage Pathways: Burial Monuments and Road Networks in Early Roman Jerusalem, Cercetări Arheologice, Vol. 31.2, pag. 347-378, 2024, doi: https://doi.org/10.46535/ca.31.2.05

Bibliography

  1. Alon Shevut. ‘Atiqot 38: 75–84.
  2. Avigad, N. 1945. Mugharet Umm el-‘Amad. Kedem: Studies in Jewish Archaeology 2: 75–82 (Hebrew).
  3. Avigad, N. 1951. The rock-carved façades of the Jerusalem necropolis. Israel Exploration Journal 1: 96–106.
  4. Avigad, N. 1954. Ancient monuments in the Qidron Valley. Jerusalem: Bialik Institute (Hebrew).
  5. Avigad, N. 1967. Jewish rock-cut tombs in Jerusalem and in the Judean hill-country. Eretz-Israel 8: 119–142 (Hebrew with English summary), http://www.jstor.org/stable/23616830.
  6. Avigad, N. 1971. The burial-vault of a Nazirite family on Mount Scopus. Israel Exploration Journal 21(4): 185– 200, http://www.jstor.org/stable/27925288.
  7. Avi-Yonah, M. 1984. Historical geography of the Land of Israel. Jerusalem: Mosad Bialik (Hebrew).
  8. Avni, G. and Greenhut, Z. 1996. The Akeldama tombs: three burial caves in the Qidron Valley: 1–39. Jerusalem: Israel Antiquities Authority.
  9. Avni, G. and Zissu, B. 2015. The “Tomb of the Prophets” on the Mount of Olives: A re-examination, in: A. E. Killebrew and G. Fassbeck (eds.) Viewing ancient Jewish art and archaeology: vehinnei Rachel, essays in honor of Rachel Hachlili: 16–32. Leiden: Brill.
  10. Barag, D. 2003. The 2000–2001 exploration of the tombs of Benei Hezir and Zechariah. Israel Exploration Journal 53(1): 78–110.
  11. Barag, D. 2010. The Tomb of Jason reconsidered, in: Z. Weiss, O. Irshai, J. Magness, and S. Schwartz (eds.) Follow the wise: studies in Jewish history and culture in honor of Lee I. Levine: 145–161. Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns.
  12. Baruch, Y. and Wiegmann, A. 2013. New discoveries concerning Jewish burial caves from the Second Temple period in Jerusalem. Hebrew Bible and Ancient Israel 3(2): 429–451, DOI:10.1628/219222713X13874428011246.
  13. Beauvery, R. 1957. La route romaine de Jerusalem à Jericho. Revue Biblique 64(1): 72–101.
  14. Ben David, C. 2014. All roads lead to Jerusalem: Aelia Capitolina and the Roman Imperial road network, in: G. D. Stiebel, O. Peleg-Barkat, D. Ben-Ami, S. Weksler-Bdolah and Y. Gadot (eds.) New studies in the archaeology of Jerusalem and its region: collected papers 7: 207–218. Jerusalem: Israel Antiquities Authority (Hebrew).
  15. Ben-Eliyahu, E. 2000. On the location of the village of Bethphage. ‘Al-’Atar 6: 51–62 (Hebrew).
  16. Berlin, A. 2002. Power and its afterlife: tombs in Hellenistic Palestine. Near Eastern Archaeology 65(2): 138–148.
  17. Bliss, F. L. and Dickie, A. C. 1898. Excavations at Jerusalem, 1894–1897. London: Committee of the Palestine Exploration Fund.
  18. Borg, B. E. 2013. Crisis and ambition: tombs and burial customs in third-century CE Rome (Oxford Studies in Ancient Culture and Representation). Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
  19. Carroll, M. and Rempel, J. 2011. Living through the dead: burial and commemoration in the classical world (Studies in Funerary Archaeology 5).Oxford: Oxbow.
  20. Carroll, M. 2006. Spirits of the dead: Roman funerary commemoration in Western Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  21. Claridge, A. 2010. Rome: an Oxford archaeological guide. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press, 2010.
  22. Coleman, S. and Eade, J. (eds.). 2004. Reframing pilgrimage: cultures in motion. New York and London: Routledge.
  23. Conder, C. R. and Kitchener, H. H. 1880. Sheet XVII, in: Map of western Palestine in 26 sheets, from surveys conducted for the Committee of the Palestine Exploration Fund. London: Palestine Exploration Fund.
  24. Conder, C. R. and Kitchener, H. H. 1883. The survey of western Palestine, vol. 3: Judea. London: Palestine Exploration Fund.
  25. Cootwijck, J. van. 1619. Itinerarium Hierosolymitanum et Syriacum. Antwerp: Ηieronymus Verdussen.
  26. Danby, H. (trans.). 1933. The Mishnah. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  27. Dickson, G. 1903. The tomb of Nicanor of Alexandria. Palestine Exploration Fund Quarterly Statement 35: 326–332.
  28. Eade, J. 2020. The invention of sacred places and rituals: a comparative study of pilgrimage. Religions 11, 649, DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/rel11120649.
  29. Ehrenheim, H. von. 2015. Greek incubation rituals in classical and Hellenistic times (Kernos, Supplément 29). Liège: Presses Universitaires de Liège.
  30. Ehrenwald, M. 2016. Sanhedriya—the northern border neighbourhood of Jerusalem: history, sites, people, and tour routes. Jerusalem: Yad Izhak Ben-Zvi (Hebrew).
  31. Epstein, I. (ed.). 1961. Babylonian Talmud. London: Soncino Press.
  32. Feldman, J. 2005. The experience of sharing and confirmation of authority: pilgrimage to Jerusalem and to the Temple during the Second Temple Period, in: O. Limor, E. Reiner, and M. Frenkel (eds.) Pilgrimage: Jews, Christians, Moslems: 88–109. Ra’anana: Open University (Hebrew).
  33. Finegan, J. 1992. The archeology of the New Testament: the life of Jesus and the beginning of the early church. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
  34. Fischer, M., 2012. Conclusions: Horvat Mesad in context, in: M. Fischer (ed.) Horvat Mesad: a way station on the Jaffa-Jerusalem road: 275–290 (Monograph Series 30). Tel Aviv: Tel Aviv University Institute of Archaeology.
  35. Fischer, M., Isaac, B. and Roll, I. 1996. Roman roads in Judaea II: the Jaffa-Jerusalem roads (BAR International Series 628). Oxford: Tempus Reparatum.
  36. Gavin, C. E. S. 1978. Bonfils and the early photography of the Near East. Harvard Library Bulletin 26(4): 442–470.
  37. Gibson, S. 2003. Jerusalem in original photographs 1850–1920: photographs from the archives of the Palestine Exploration Fund. Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns.
  38. Goodman, M. 1999. The pilgrimage economy of Jerusalem in the Second Temple period, in: L. I. Levine (ed.) Jerusalem: its sanctity and centrality to Judaism, Christianity, and Islam: 69–76. New York: Continuum.
  39. Goodman, M. 2007. The pilgrimage economy of Jerusalem in the Second Temple period, in: M. Goodman (ed.) Judaism in the Roman world: collected essays: 60–61. Leiden and Boston: Brill.
  40. Gröber, K. 1926. Palestine and Syria: the country, the people and the landscape. New York and Berlin: Via-Lens.
  41. Guggenheimer, H. W. (ed. and trans.). 1999–2015. The Jerusalem Talmud. Berlin: De Gruyter.
  42. Hachlili, R. 2005. Jewish funerary customs, practices and rites in the Second Temple period. Leiden: Brill.
  43. Hagbi, M., Szanton, N., Uziel, J. and Levy, A. 2022. Jerusalem, City of David, the stepped street. Hadashot Arkheologiyot: Excavations and Surveys in Israel 134, https://www.hadashot-esi.org.il/Report_Detail_eng. aspx?print=all&id=26183.
  44. Hollinshead, M. B. 2015. Shaping ceremony: monumental steps in Greek architecture. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
  45. Hope, V. M. 2009. Roman death: the dying and the dead in ancient Rome. London: Bloomsbury.
  46. Hunter-Crawley, H. 2017. Movement as sacred mimesis at Abu Mena and Qal’at Sim’an, in: W. Friese and T. M. Kristensen (eds.) Excavating pilgrimage: archaeological approaches to sacred travel and movement in the ancient Mediterranean and Near East: 187–202. London and New York: Routledge.
  47. Jeremias, J. 1962. Jerusalem zur Zeit Jesu. Gottingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.
  48. Josephus. 1956–1961. The Jewish War, trans. H. St. J. Thackeray, vols. 2–3. London: William Heinemann; Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
  49. Josephus. 1957–1995. Jewish Antiquities, trans. H. St. J. Thackeray, vols. 1–4. London: William Heinemann; Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
  50. Jotham-Rothschild, J. 1952. The tombs of Sanhedria. Palestine Exploration Quarterly 84(1): 23–38, DOI:10.1179/ peq.1952.84.1.23.
  51. Kloner, A. 1996. Stepped roads in Roman Palestine. Aram 8(1): 111–137.
  52. Kloner, A. 2002. Survey of Jerusalem: the northeastern sector (Archaeological Survey of Israel). Jerusalem: Israel Antiquities Authority.
  53. Kloner, A. 2003. Survey of Jerusalem: the northwest sector: introduction and indices (Archaeological Survey of Israel). Jerusalem: Israel Antiquities Authority.
  54. Kloner, A. and Zissu, B. 2002. The “Caves of Simeon the Just” and “The Minor Sanhedrin”: two burial complexes from the Second Temple period in Jerusalem, in: L. V. Rutgers (ed.) What Athens has to do with Jerusalem: essays on classical, Jewish, and early Christian art and archaeology in honor of Gideon Foerster: 125–149 (Interdisciplinary Studies in Ancient Culture and Religion 1). Leuven: Peeters.
  55. Kloner, A. and Zissu, B. 2007. The necropolis of Jerusalem in the Second Temple period. Leuven and Dudley, MA: Peeters.
  56. Kon, M. 1947. The Tombs of the Kings. Tel Aviv: Dvir (Hebrew).
  57. Levine, L. I. 1999. A Jewish city in the Greco-Roman orbit, in: L. I. Levine (ed.) Jerusalem: its sanctity and centrality to Judaism, Christianity, and Islam: 53–68. New York: Continuum.
  58. Levine L. I. 2002. Jerusalem: portrait of the city in the Second Temple period (538 BCE–70 CE). Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society,
  59. Magen, Y. 2008. Tombs ornamented in Jerusalem style in Samaria and the Hebron Hills, in: Y. Magen (ed.) Judea and Samaria researches and discoveries: 141–164. Jerusalem: Israel Antiquities Authority.
  60. Morinis, E. A. 1992. Introduction, in: E. A. Morinis (ed.) Sacred journeys: the anthropology of pilgrimage: 1–30. Westport and London: Greenwood.
  61. Neusner, J. (ed.). 1977–1986. The Tosefta: Second Division: Moed. New York: Ktav.
  62. Patterson, J. 2000. Living and dying in the city of Rome: houses and tombs, in: J. Coulston and H. Dodge (eds.) Ancient Rome: the archaeology of the Eternal City: 259–289 (Oxford University School of Archaeology Monograph 54). Oxford: Oxbow.
  63. Peleg-Barkat, O. 2012. The relative chronology of tomb façades in Early Roman Jerusalem and power displays by the élite. Journal of Roman Archaeology 25(1): 403–418.
  64. Peleg-Barkat, O. 2015. Decorated tomb façades in Early Roman Jerusalem and their influence on the decoration of tombs in Judaea and Samaria, in: Y. Ben-Arieh et al. (eds.) Study of Jerusalem through the ages: 73−121. Jerusalem: Yad Izhak Ben-Zvi (Hebrew).
  65. Peleg-Barkat, O. 2016. Interpreting the uninterpreted: art as a means of expressing identity in Early Roman Judaea, in: U. Leibner and C. Hezser (eds.) Jewish art in its late antique context: 27–48 (Texts and Studies in Ancient Judaism 163). Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck.
  66. Peleg-Barkat, O. 2022. The façade of the Tel Arza burial cave: architectural style and a comparative study. ‘Atiqot 106: 177–186.
  67. Philo of Alexandria. 1937. The Special Laws, in: Philo, vol. 7, trans. F. H. Colson: 97–607 (Loeb Classical Library). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
  68. Porat, R., Chachy, R. and Kalman, Y. 2015. Herodium: final reports of the 1972–2010 excavations, directed by Ehud Netzer, vol. 1: Herod’s tomb precinct. Jerusalem: Israel Exploration Society.
  69. Rahmani, L. Y. 1967. Jason’s Tomb. Israel Exploration Journal 17: 61–100.
  70. Rahmani, L. Y. 1981. Ancient Jerusalem’s funerary customs and tombs. Biblical Archeologist 44(3): 171–177.
  71. Rahmani, L. Y. 1982. Ancient Jerusalem’s funerary customs and tombs. Biblical Archeologist 45(2): 109–118.
  72. Rahmani, L. Y. 1994a. A catalogue of Jewish ossuaries in the collections of the State of Israel. Jerusalem: Israel Antiquities Authority.
  73. Rahmani, L. Y. 1994b. Ossuaries and ossilegium (bone-gathering) in the late Second Temple period, in: H. Geva (ed.) Ancient Jerusalem revealed: 191–205. Jerusalem: Israel Exploration Society.
  74. Raviv, D. and Zissu, B. 2018. Rock-cut water cisterns and ritual baths alongside Second Temple period pilgrims’ roads to Jerusalem: a reexamination. Speleology and Spelestology 1: 146–167.
  75. Raviv, D. and Zissu, B. 2020. Tombs with decorated façades in the Judean countryside. Zeitschrift des Deutschen Palästina-Vereins 136(2): 152–175.
  76. Regev, E. 2004. Family burial, family structure, and the urbanization of Herodian Jerusalem. Palestine Exploration Quarterly 136(2): 109–131. DOI:10.1179/003103204×4058.
  77. Reich, R. 2019. The evaluation of F. J. Bliss and A. Dickie’s excavations in the City of David and Tyropoeon Valley in Jerusalem, in the light of recent excavations, in: D. Gurevich and A. Kidron (eds.) Exploring the Holy Land: 150 years of the Palestine Exploration Fund: 61–80. Sheffield: Equinox.
  78. Reich, R. and Shukron, E. 2011. The Pool of Siloam in Jerusalem of the late Second Temple period and its surroundings, in: K. Galor and G. Avni (eds.) Unearthing Jerusalem: 150 years of archaeological research in the holy city: 241–255. Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns.
  79. Richardson, L. Jr. 1992. A new topographical dictionary of ancient Rome. Johns Hopkins University Press.
  80. Roll, I. 1983. The Roman road system in Judaea, in: The Jerusalem Cathedra 3: 136–181. Jerusalem: Yad Izhak Ben-Zvi; Detroit: Wayne State University Press.
  81. Roll, I. 1994. Roman roads, in: Y. Tsafrir, L. Di Segni, and J. Green, Tabula Imperii Romani: Iudaea, Palaestina: Eretz Israel in the Hellenistic, Roman and Byzantine periods: maps and gazetteer: 18–19. Jerusalem: Israel Science Foundation.
  82. Safrai, S. 1981. Die Wallfahrt im Zeitalter des Zweiten Tempels. Neukirchen-Vluyn: Neukirchener.
  83. Shear, J. L. 2021. Serving Athena: the Festival of the Panathenaia and the construction of Athenian identities. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press.
  84. Shtober-Zisu, N. and Zissu, B. 2018. Lithology and the distribution of Early Roman-era tombs in Jerusalem’s necropolis. Progress in Physical Geography 42(5): 628–649.
  85. Shukrun, E. and Reich, R. 1999. The area to the east of the Temple Mount in Jerusalem during the Second Temple, Roman, and Byzantine periods in light of the 1995–1998 excavations, in: A. Faust and E. Baruch (eds.) New studies on Jerusalem 5: 113–116.
  86. Simeon of Frankfurt. 2017. Yalkut Shimoni. Jerusalem: Or Hahayyim (Hebrew).
  87. Slouschz, N. 1925. The excavations around the Tomb of Absalom. Bulletin of the Jewish Palestine Exploration Society 1(2): 5–48 (Hebrew).
  88. Stroszeck, J. 2014. Der Kerameikos in Athen: Geschichte, Bauten und Denkmäler im archäologischen Park. Bad Langensalza: Bibliopolis.
  89. Szanton, N., Hagbi, M., Uziel, J. and Ariel, D. T. 2019. Pontius Pilate in Jerusalem: the monumental street from the Siloam Pool to the Temple Mount. Tel Aviv 46(2): 147–166.
  90. Tepper, Y. and Tepper Y. 2013. The road that bears the people: pilgrimage roads to Jerusalem in the Second Temple period. Bnei Brak: Hakibbutz Hameuchad (Hebrew).
  91. Thomsen, P. 1917. Die roemischen Meilensteine der Provinzen Syria, Arabia, und Palastina. Zeitschrift des Deutschen Palästina-Vereins 40: 1–103.
  92. Trigger, B. G. 1990. Monumental architecture: a thermodynamic explanation of symbolic behaviour World Archaeology 22(2): 119–132.
  93. Turner, V. 1974. Pilgrimages as social processes, in: Dramas, fields, and metaphors: symbolic action in human society: 166–230. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
  94. Urry, J. and Larsen, J. 2011. The Tourist Gaze 3.0. New York: Sage.
  95. Ussishkin, D. 1993. The village of Silwan: the necropolis from the period of the Judean kingdom. Jerusalem: Israel Exploration Society and Yad Izhak Ben-Zvi.
  96. Wiegmann, A. and Baruch, Y. 2022. A monumental burial cave in the Tel Arza neighborhood, Jerusalem. ‘Atiqot 106: 161–176.
  97. Wilkinson, J. 1975. The way from Jerusalem to Jericho. The Biblical Archaeologist 38: 10–24.
  98. Zissu, B. 1995. Jerusalem, Shemuel Hanavi Street. Excavations and Surveys in Israel 14: 144–145.
  99. Zissu, B., Bickson, D. and Raviv, D. 2023. An archaeological survey at the Shalmon spur (Nahal Refaim) in the Jerusalem highlands. Speleology and Spelestology 2023(3): 43–59.
  100. Zissu, B. and Kloner, A. 2009. Cisterns in Ras Tumeim, east of Jerusalem, in: J. Geiger, H. M. Cotton, and G. D. Stiebel (eds.) Israel’s land: papers presented to Israel Shatzman on his jubilee: 99–113. Ra’anana: Open University (Hebrew).
  101. Zissu, B. and Tendler, A. S. 2011. The Kidron Valley tombs in the Byzantine period: a reconsideration, in: E. Baruch, A. Levy-Reifer, and A. Faust (eds.) New studies on Jerusalem 17: 7*–43*. Ramat Gan: Ingeborg Rennert Center, Bar-Ilan University.

Creative Commons Licence
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License