Analyzing the Visual and Conceptual Patterns of the Ibex Motif on the Pottery of Tall-I Bakun of Fars, Iran (5th and 4th Millennia BC) using the Iconology Approach of Erwin Panofsky

Cercetări Arheologice 32.1, 2025, 11-26
https://doi.org/10.46535/ca.32.1.01



Analyzing the Visual and Conceptual Patterns of the Ibex Motif on the Pottery of Tall-I Bakun of Fars, Iran (5th and 4th Millennia BC) using the Iconology Approach of Erwin Panofsky

Authors: Sasan Samanian Sareh Bahmani Mohammad Hossein Rezaei

Keywords:

Iconology, Erwin Panofsky, Ibex, Tall-i Bakun, Pottery, Motif

Abstract:

The art of ancient Iran, replete with pictorial elements, encapsulates themes and concepts that have intrigued scholars since the earliest encounters with imagery. These elements, especially prevalent in pottery designs, offer a window into the cognitive intricacies of the ancient human psyche. Iconology, a methodological approach in art interpretation pioneered by Erwin Panofsky, employs a layered analysis to decipher the meaning behind visual arts. This study aims to dissect the visual and conceptual patterns of the ibex motif found on the pottery of Tall-i Bakun in Fars (5th and 4th millennia BC). It specifically addresses how the ibex motif can be interpreted through Panofsky’s tripartite framework of meaning. The findings suggest that iconological analysis can effectively unravel the original and ancient motifs of Tall-i Bakun in Fars. It posits that these motifs, steeped in ritualistic, cultural, and geographical contexts, reflect the broader ethos of Iranian art and culture. The recurrent motifs of the mountain ibex, emblematic of lunar associations, water, and fertility wishes, underscore the elemental significance and the continuum of life in the region’s iconography.

Download: PDF

How to cite: Sasan Samanian, Sareh Bahmani, Mohammad Hossein Rezaei, Analyzing the Visual and Conceptual Patterns of the Ibex Motif on the Pottery of Tall-I Bakun of Fars, Iran (5th and 4th Millennia BC) using the Iconology Approach of Erwin Panofsky, Cercetări Arheologice, Vol. 32.1, pag. 11-26, 2025, doi: https://doi.org/10.46535/ca.32.1.01

Bibliography

  1. Abdi, N. 2012. An Introduction to iconology: Theory and application of a case study of Iranian painting. Tehran: Sokhan. (Original text in Persian).
  2. Alizadeh, A. 1988a. Mobile Pastoralism and the Development of Complex Societies in Highland Iran: The Evidence from Tall-I Bakun A., Ph.D dissertation, Department of Near Eastern Language and Civilizations, University of Chicago.
  3. Alizadeh, A. 1988b. Socio-Economic Complexity in Southwestern Iran during the Fifth and Fourth Millennia B.C.: The Evidence from Tall-i Bakun A. Iran, 26: 17–34. https://doi.org/10.2307/4299798.
  4. Alizadeh, A. 2006. The Origins of State Organizations in Prehistoric Highland Fars, Southern Iran: Excavations at Tall-i Bakun. Oriental Institute Publications, Vol. 128. The Oriental institute of the University of Chicago. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
  5. Amouzgar, J. 2001. The mythological history of Iran. Tehran: Samt Publications. (Original text in Persian).
  6. Azizi Kharanaghi, M, Salehi, M. and Zayeri, F. 2017. The Association between Motif and Form in Middle Bakun Ceramics of Toll-e Rahmatabad in Fars Region (Fifth Millennium BC), using Statistical Linear Models. International Journal of the Society of Iranian Archaeologists, 3(5): 23-30.
  7. Cooper, J. C. 2000. Illustrated dictionary of traditional symbols. (M. Karbasian, Trans.). Tehran: Farshad Publications. (Original text in Persian).
  8. Dadvar, A., GH. Bahmani, S. and Samanian, S. 2013. Human and animal symbols found in potteries of three regions of Tall-i Bakun of Fars, Tepe Sialk of Kashan, and Tepe Gyan of Nahavand. Comparative Art Studies biannual, 4 (8): 1-14. (Original text in Persian).
  9. Durant, W. 1991. History of civilization. (A. Aram Moghadam, Trans.). First volume, Tehran: Islamic Revolution Publications and Education. (Original text in Persian).
  10. Egami, N. and Sono, T. 1959. Marv-Dasht: The excavation at Tall-i-Gap. Tokyo.
  11. Egami, N. and Masuda, S. I. 1958. Tall-i-Bakun, a Report of the Archaeological Excavation in Southwestern Iran. Institute for Oriental Culture University of Tokyo.
  12. Eqtedari, A. 1965. Diyar Shahriaran. The first volume of historical works and monuments of Khuzestan, Tehran: Publications of the Association of National Art.
  13. Farhadi, M. 1998. Museums in the wind. Tehran: Allameh Tabatabaie University Publications. (Original text in Persian).
  14. Ghirshman, R. 1999. Sialk Kashan (the oldest human habitat in the plateau of Iran). first volume, translation: Asghar Karimi, Tehran: Publication of Research Institute of Cultural Heritage & Tourism. (Original text in Persian).
  15. Hall, J. 2001. Pictorial dictionary of symbols in the art of the East and the West. (R. Behzadi, Trans.). Tehran: Farhang Moaser. (Original text in Persian).
  16. Hertzfeld, E. 2002. Iran in the Ancient East (1st edition) (H. Sanatizadeh, Trans.). Tehran, Publications of Humanities and Cultural Studies Research Center and Shahid Bahonar University of Kerman.
  17. Hinnells, J. 1995. Understanding the myths of Iran. (J. Amouzgar and A. Tafazoli, Trans.). Tehran: Cheshme Publishing House. (Original text in Persian).
  18. Jobes, G. 1991. Symbols. Book 1: Animals. (M. R. Baghapour, Trans.). Tehran: Translation Publisher. (Original text in Persian).
  19. Kambakhsh Fard, S. 2005. Pottery and pottery-work in Iran from the beginning of the Neolithic to the modern era. Tehran: Ghoghnoos Publications. (Original text in Persian).
  20. Karimi, B. 1967. Aryan civilization and their trajectory and Lorestan Bronze. Journal of Historical Studies, 6: 114- 124. (Original text in Persian).
  21. Kippenberg, H. J. 1992. Iconography and religion. Farhang Journal, 4 (16): 139-147. (Original text in Persian).
  22. Kyani, M, Y. 2000. History of pottery and pottery-work in Iran.Tehran: Danesh. (Original text in Persian).
  23. Langsdorff, A. and McCown, D. E. 1942. Tal-I-Bakun A., Oriental Institute Publication No. 59. Oriental Institute University of Chicago: 1-4.
  24. Maani, M. Saedi Harsini, M. and Chaychi, A. 2019. A Preliminary Report on the Petrographic Analysis of Bakun A Potteries of Fars Province. Journal of Archaeological Studies, 11(1): 217-232. (Original text in Persian).25
  25. Malek Shahmirzadi, S. 1999. Prehistoric Iran: Iran from the Earliest Times to the Dawn of Urbanism. (Original text in Persian).
  26. Research Deputy of Cultural Heritage Organization Press, Tehran. (Original text in Persian).
  27. Mehraz, R. 1988. Human ideals in Iranian culture and art. Tehran: National University of Iran. (Original text in Persian).
  28. Mitford, M, B. 2009. Illustrated dictionary of symbols and signs in the world. (A. Dadvar and Z. Taran, Trans). Tehran: Kalhor, Al-Zahra University. (Original text in Persian).
  29. Mohammad Beygi, A. 2015. Ibex, Man’s old friend. Hunting and Nature Conservation Quarterly, 41: 76-77. (Original text in Persian).
  30. Naseri Fard, M. 2012. Ibex petroglyphs. Hunting and Nature Conservation Quarterly, 29: 73. (Original text in Persian).
  31. Nasri, A. 2018. Image and word: An approach to iconography. Tehran: Cheshme. Oriental Institute Museum, University of Chicago Chicago, Illinois, USA. (Original text in Persian)
  32. Pakbaz, R. 2000. Iranian paintings from long ago to today. Tehran: Zarin and Simin Publications. (Original text in Persian).
  33. Panofsky, E. 1972. Studies in Iconology (Humanistic Themes in Art of the Renaissance). Icon Editions, New York. (Original text in Persian).
  34. Panofsky, E. 2014. An introduction to the study of Renaissance art. (R. Ghafouri, Trans.). Ketab Mah Honar, 187: 64-71.
  35. Pope, A. U. 2008. A Journey in Iranian Art. Volume 7. Tehran: Elmi Farhangi. (Original text in Persian).
  36. Pope, A. U. 2001. Masterpieces of Iranian art. (P. Natelkhanlari, Trans.). Tehran: Elmi Farhangi. (Original text in Persian).
  37. Rouhfar, Z. 1990. Mythological motifs in Buyid fabrics. Cultural Heritage Journal, 1: 12-15. (Original text in Persian).
  38. Saberi, N. Mafi Tabar, A. 2020. The symbolism of the birds motifs in Sasanid textiles from the perspective of Erwin Panofsky’s iconology, Rahpooye Honar Journal, Visual Arts, 6: 5-13. (Original text in Persian).
  39. Seyyedan, Sh. 2002. Nahavand in the millennia of history. Tehran: Ashti. (Original text in Persian)
  40. Vanden Berghe, L. 1969. Archaeology of ancient Iran, translation: Isa Behnam, Tehran University Publications. (Original text in Persian).
  41. Wilson, J. Ch. 1988. History of Iranian industries. (A. Faryar, Trans). Tehran: Farhangsara Publication. https://isac. uchicago.edu/gallery/prehistoric-mound-tall-i-bakun. (Original text in Persian).

Creative Commons Licence
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License